Montana Democrats Vote Against Bill Banning Sharia Law, Call It ‘Repugnant’

Clare Lopez: “There’s a real misconception out there about these ALAC & ALAC-type bills – ALAC stands for ‘American Laws for American Courts’ – it doesn’t ban any law outright, not French law or Chinese law or Singaporean law or shariah – it says if ever there’s a conflict in US Courts w/US Constitutional law, then American law will prevail. Very common sense, totally inoffensive to anyone.”

Breitbart, by Ben Kew, March 31, 2017:

Democrats in Montana have opposed a bill banning the use of foreign law in its state courts on the grounds that such legislation would target Muslims.

Senate Bill 97, introduced by Keith Regier (R-Kalispell) bans the application of foreign law in Montana’s courts, with the debate particularly focused on Sharia Law, a form of Islamic law typically used in the Middle East.

Although the bill passed on party lines by 56-44, Democrats claimed it was designed to target Muslim communities.

“I think it sends a dangerous message to minority groups both here living in our state and wanting to come visit our state, just merely on the fact that you may be different,” said Rep. Shane Morigeau, D-Missoula, while debating the bill. “I truly believe this law is repugnant. I believe this is not who we are as Montanans.”

Meanwhile, Rep. Ellie Hill Smith (D-Missoula) proposed a failed amendment to the bill to include a ban on both Sharia Law and the Law of Moses, in order to “show the state of Montana that it is not just about Islamic Law.”

“The courts have said that laws that single out certain religions violate the First Amendment,” Smith said, claiming that it was “peppered with anti-Muslim bigotry.”

Another Democrat, Rep. Laurie Bishop (D-Livingston) urged legislators “not to forget the roots of this bill,” adding that “our children are watching.”

Meanwhile, Rep. Brad Tschida (R-Missoula) said the bill was an attempt to push back against a “constitution [that] is constantly under assault.”

Bills specifically targeting Sharia Law have passed in states such as North Carolina, Alabama, Arizona, Kansas, Louisiana, South Dakota, and Tennessee. The bill will now be passed on to Gov. Steve Bullock (D) for signature or veto.

You can follow Ben Kew on Facebook, on Twitter at @ben_kew, or email him at

One thought on “Montana Democrats Vote Against Bill Banning Sharia Law, Call It ‘Repugnant’

  1. The Constitution of our Republic form of government is the rule of law to be respected and honored by the citizens of the United States and by those who live here. If you cannot you
    have every right to leave for places that conform to your beliefs. You are not being held hostage.
    You chose to come here. Conform or get the hell out.

Comments are closed.